Joel Halliday

Goalkeeper - Dinamo Makhachkala 2
17 Sep 2028
Sunday
Process
Overview Personal Contract News 29 Transfers Relations Events 97 Awards Matches History

Events

97

  1. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  2. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  3. Dreams of genuine first-team football

    Moderate
    Cause
    He has spent years in the reserves and wants a real chance at first-team level. (He has been stuck in the reserve squad for a long time.)
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  4. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  5. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  6. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  7. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  8. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Moderate
    Cause
    He is unhappy about his playing time. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  9. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  10. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  11. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  12. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  13. Dreams of genuine first-team football

    Moderate
    Cause
    He has spent years in the reserves and wants a real chance at first-team level. (He has been stuck in the reserve squad for a long time.)
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  14. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  15. Asking for a language tutor

    Serious
    Cause
    The language barrier is wearing on him.; He still does not speak the local language.

  16. Worried by competition from a new signing Vladimir Zadiraka

    Moderate
    Cause
    The new arrival has visibly higher ability. The newcomer is on a much larger wage deal.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  17. Worried by competition from a new signing Ilja Kuptsov

    Moderate
    Cause
    The new arrival has visibly higher ability. The newcomer is on a much larger wage deal.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  18. Worried by competition from a new signing Daniil Silev

    Moderate
    Cause
    The new arrival has visibly higher ability. He was already short on minutes before the signing arrived.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  19. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Moderate
    Cause
    His relationship with the manager has soured. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  20. Difficult conversation with the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  21. Difficult conversation with the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  22. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  23. Struggling to settle into the squad

    Minor
    Cause
    The settling-in period at a new club is the bigger picture. The language gap is making integration harder.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  24. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Serious
    Cause
    His relationship with the manager has soured. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  25. Difficult conversation with the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  26. Returned to full training after injury

    Minor
    Cause
    The medical team cleared him, but the staff are protecting him from a rushed comeback.

  27. Given a personal development plan

  28. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Moderate
    Cause
    His relationship with the manager has soured. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  29. Manager broke a promise

    Moderate
    Cause
    Even an honest tone was resented given the strained relationship.

  30. Asking for a language tutor

    Serious
    Cause
    The language barrier is wearing on him.; He still does not speak the local language.

  31. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Serious
    Cause
    He is unhappy about his playing time. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  32. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  33. Manager trust is eroding

    Major
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his recent performance level. Staff had already warned him about this in the last few weeks.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  34. Named Player of the Match

  35. Reassured by a calm full-time message

    Minor
    Cause
    The moment called for a quiet show of support. He does not always respond well to pressure, which softened the lift.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  36. An off-day in training

    Minor
    Cause
    Nothing unusual — just a quieter day at the training ground.

  37. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Moderate
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  38. Dropped to the bench as Ben Clark was preferred

    Minor
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  39. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  40. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  41. Left out as Ben Clark was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  42. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  43. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  44. Dropped to the bench as Ben Clark was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  45. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  46. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  47. Dropped to the bench as Ben Clark was preferred

    Serious
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  48. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  49. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Serious
    Cause
    He is unhappy about his playing time. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  50. Hard conversation with the manager about playing time

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  51. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  52. Dropped to the bench as Ben Clark was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  53. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  54. Promised more playing time by the manager

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  55. Hard conversation with the manager about playing time

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  56. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  57. Left out as Ben Clark was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  58. Hurt by being benched for a big match

    Major
    Cause
    The manager left him out of the starting XI. in the title decider
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  59. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  60. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Serious
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — a chance to give him cup minutes.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  61. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  62. Dropped to the bench as Ben Clark was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  63. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  64. Left out as Ben Clark was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  65. Manager trust is eroding

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his recent performance level. Staff had already warned him about this in the last few weeks.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  66. Settling well into the dressing room

    Minor
    Cause
    A strong training-ground partnership is behind this. The bond between them was already strong, so the morale hit should be limited.
    Outlook
    Settling-in period is still under way.

  67. His club is fighting to avoid relegation

    Serious
    Cause
    The points gap to safety, with matches running out, is the issue.

  68. Praised by the manager

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  69. Loan listing accepted

    Moderate
    Cause
    The clubs have agreed in principle to take him on loan.

  70. Left out as Nikita Karabashev was preferred

    Major
    Chosen instead
    Nikita Karabashev was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  71. Dropped to the bench as Ben Clark was preferred

    Serious
    Chosen instead
    Ben Clark was preferred — longer time settled at the club.
    Cause
    He is left out while unsettled over his future at the club.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  72. Difficult conversation with the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  73. Difficult conversation with the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  74. Squad status changed

  75. Manager broke a promise

    Serious
    Cause
    Even an honest tone was resented given the strained relationship.

  76. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  77. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Minor
    Cause
    He is unhappy about his playing time. His relationship with the manager is steady but tense.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  78. Hard conversation with the manager about playing time

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  79. Asking for a language tutor

    Moderate
    Cause
    The language barrier is wearing on him.; He still does not speak the local language.

  80. Hard conversation with the manager about playing time

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  81. Stayed on the bench all match

    Minor
    Cause
    The bench was built around different match options.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  82. Struggling to settle into the squad

    Moderate
    Cause
    The settling-in period at a new club is the bigger picture. The language gap is making integration harder.
    Outlook
    Settling-in period is still under way.

  83. Reassured by a calm full-time message

    Minor
    Cause
    The team had won, and the manager wanted to reinforce the standards. He does not always respond well to pressure, which softened the lift.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  84. Administrative demotion

    Decision
    Movement
    Dinamo Makhachkala → Dinamo Makhachkala 2
    Who
    Malakhov Andrey

  85. Board transfer-listed

    Decision
    Cause
    Underutilized, surplus to requirements
    Who
    Board

  86. Struggling to settle into the squad

    Moderate
    Cause
    The settling-in period at a new club is the bigger picture. The language gap is making integration harder.
    Outlook
    Settling-in period is still under way.

  87. Struggling to settle into the squad

    Moderate
    Cause
    The settling-in period at a new club is the bigger picture. The language gap is making integration harder.
    Outlook
    Settling-in period is still under way.

  88. Reassured by a calm full-time message

    Minor
    Cause
    The moment called for a quiet show of support. He does not always respond well to pressure, which softened the lift.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  89. Contract extension signed

    Decision
    Movement
    3y · $203.7K/y

  90. Contract renewal offered

    Decision
    Movement
    3y · $203.7K/y

  91. Free transfer

    Decision
    Movement
    Legion → Dinamo Makhachkala

  92. Pre-contract agreed

    Decision
    Movement
    → Dinamo Makhachkala

  93. Contract renewal offered

    Decision
    Movement
    3y · $73.2K/y

  94. Contract renewal offered

    Decision
    Movement
    3y · $67.2K/y

  95. Contract renewal rejected

    Decision
    Movement
    3y · $59.1K/y

  96. Contract renewal offered

    Decision
    Movement
    3y · $59.1K/y

  97. Signed as a free agent

    Decision
    Movement
    Legion