Benjamin Hall

Defensive Midfielder - Manchester City
14 Nov 2027
Sunday
Process
Overview Personal Contract News 2 Transfers Relations Events 105 Awards 1 Matches History

Events

105
Severity
Mood

  1. Stayed back for extra training

    Moderate
    Cause
    He stayed back for extra work after the rest of the squad had gone in.

  2. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  3. Breakthrough into the senior squad

  4. Led the defence in a tight match

    Minor
    Cause
    He held the back line together when the game was hanging in the balance.

  5. Praised in a satisfied full-time talk

    Minor
    Cause
    The team had won, and the manager wanted to reinforce the standards. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  6. He has come to believe: Bad blood between them — Josh Wilson-Esbrand

    Mind

  7. Personality clash with Lakyle Samuel

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  8. Built a stronger partnership with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    A strong training-ground partnership is behind this. Previous friction meant this was not treated as a one-off.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  9. Praised by manager

    Major
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  10. Promised playing time by manager

  11. Stayed back for extra training

    Moderate
    Cause
    He stayed back for extra work after the rest of the squad had gone in.

  12. Personality clash with Josh Wilson-Esbrand

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  13. Praised by manager

    Major
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  14. Promised playing time by manager

  15. To be loaned out

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board

  16. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  17. He has come to believe: Bad blood between them — Lakyle Samuel

    Mind

  18. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  19. Praised by manager

    Major
    Cause
    The discussion focused on playing time.

  20. Promised playing time by manager

  21. Personality clash with Lakyle Samuel

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  22. Built a stronger partnership with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    A strong training-ground partnership is behind this. Previous friction meant this was not treated as a one-off.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  23. Loan withdrawn

    Decision
    Cause
    No club took him on loan before the window closed
    Who
    Board

  24. Being reassessed

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board

  25. He has come to believe: He never rated him — Alexander Ellis

    Mind

  26. Unsettled by the squad wage hierarchy

    Moderate
    Cause
    The squad's wage hierarchy is the underlying issue. The gap to the squad's top earners has become a daily reminder.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  27. Personality clash with Josh Wilson-Esbrand

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  28. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  29. Worried by competition from a new signing Gabriel

    Minor
    Cause
    The new arrival has visibly higher ability. The newcomer is on a much larger wage deal.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  30. Personality clash with Lakyle Samuel

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  31. Built a stronger partnership with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    A strong training-ground partnership is behind this. Previous friction meant this was not treated as a one-off.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  32. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  33. Praised by the manager for his attitude

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his attitude.

  34. Impressed senior staff in training

    Moderate
    Cause
    His application and quality stood out for someone at this stage of his development.

  35. Personality clash with Josh Wilson-Esbrand

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  36. Unsettled by the squad wage hierarchy

    Minor
    Cause
    The squad's wage hierarchy is the underlying issue. The gap to the squad's top earners has become a daily reminder.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  37. Matheus Nunes, a close friend, was sold by the club

    Moderate
    Cause
    Losing a close friend at the club is still felt. The bond between them was already strong, so the morale hit should be limited.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  38. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  39. Worried by competition from a new signing Declan Rice

    Minor
    Cause
    The new arrival has visibly higher ability. The newcomer is on a much larger wage deal.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  40. He has come to believe: He won everything here — Manchester City

    Mind

  41. Worried by competition from a new signing Christos Mouzakitis

    Minor
    Cause
    The new arrival has visibly higher ability. The newcomer is on a much larger wage deal.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  42. Unsettled by the squad wage hierarchy

    Moderate
    Cause
    The squad's wage hierarchy is the underlying issue. The gap to the squad's top earners has become a daily reminder.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  43. Given a personal development plan

  44. Personality clash with Lakyle Samuel

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  45. Personality clash with Divin Mubama

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  46. Lifted a trophy with the team

  47. Personality clash with Ryan McAidoo

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  48. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  49. Won the domestic cup with the team

    Serious
    Cause
    Ongoing dressing-room dynamics drove this.

  50. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  51. Personality clash with Abdukodir Khusanov

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  52. Led the defence in a tight match

    Minor
    Cause
    He held the back line together when the game was hanging in the balance.

  53. Reassured by a calm full-time message

    Minor
    Cause
    The team had won, and the manager wanted to reinforce the standards. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  54. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  55. Praised by the manager for his attitude

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his attitude.

  56. He has come to believe: Bad blood between them — Oliver Lynch

    Mind

  57. He has made a formal demand: To be paid what he is worth

    Mind

  58. Stayed back for extra training

    Moderate
    Cause
    He stayed back for extra work after the rest of the squad had gone in.

  59. Praised by the manager for his attitude

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his attitude.

  60. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  61. He has said it out loud: A loan, for games

    Mind

  62. Personality clash with Abdukodir Khusanov

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  63. Led the defence in a tight match

    Minor
    Cause
    He held the back line together when the game was hanging in the balance.

  64. Praised in a satisfied full-time talk

    Minor
    Cause
    The team had won, and the manager wanted to reinforce the standards. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  65. Unsettled by the squad wage hierarchy

    Moderate
    Cause
    The squad's wage hierarchy is the underlying issue. The gap to the squad's top earners has become a daily reminder.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  66. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  67. Loan withdrawn

    Decision
    Cause
    No club took him on loan before the window closed
    Who
    Board

  68. Being reassessed

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board

  69. To be loaned out

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board

  70. Led the defence in a tight match

    Minor
    Cause
    He held the back line together when the game was hanging in the balance.

  71. Frustrated by another early substitution

    Moderate
    Cause
    He was substituted while playing well. (min 72 — rating 7.3)
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  72. Stung by a half-time roasting

    Minor
    Cause
    It was a private show of faith after a tough recent run. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  73. Praised in a satisfied full-time talk

    Minor
    Cause
    The team had won, and the manager wanted to reinforce the standards. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  74. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  75. He has come to believe: Bad blood between them — Enzo Fernández

    Mind

  76. Asked the manager for a private conversation

    Moderate
    Cause
    His relationship with the manager has soured. Manager trust is low. He has already raised this with the manager recently.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  77. Difficult conversation with the manager

    Moderate
    Cause
    The discussion covered general matters.

  78. Praised by the manager

    Major
    Cause
    A supportive tone left him motivated to respond.

  79. Personality clash with Abdukodir Khusanov

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  80. Personality clash with Ryan McAidoo

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  81. He has started to want: His place back

    Mind

  82. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  83. He got what he wanted: His place back

    Mind

  84. He has said it out loud: To be paid what he is worth

    Mind

  85. He has come to believe: Bad blood between them — Ryan McAidoo

    Mind

  86. Unsettled by the squad wage hierarchy

    Minor
    Cause
    The squad's wage hierarchy is the underlying issue. The gap to the squad's top earners has become a daily reminder.
    Outlook
    Contract request risk increased.

  87. Led the defence in a tight match

    Minor
    Cause
    He held the back line together when the game was hanging in the balance.

  88. Frustrated by another early substitution

    Moderate
    Cause
    He was substituted while playing well. (min 69 — rating 7.0)
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  89. Stung by a half-time roasting

    Minor
    Cause
    It was a private show of faith after a tough recent run. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Manager intervention may be required if it persists.

  90. Reassured by a calm full-time message

    Minor
    Cause
    The team had won, and the manager wanted to reinforce the standards. His professionalism usually steers him back from these moments.
    Outlook
    Trend is improving — relationship should keep strengthening.

  91. Personality clash with Oliver Lynch

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Likely to settle unless repeated within the next few weeks.

  92. Given a personal development plan

  93. Praised by the manager for his attitude

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his attitude.

  94. Personality clash with Abdukodir Khusanov

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  95. Personality clash with Ryan McAidoo

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  96. Manager broke a promise

    Serious
    Cause
    Even an honest tone was resented given the strained relationship.

  97. Stayed back for extra training

    Moderate
    Cause
    He stayed back for extra work after the rest of the squad had gone in.

  98. Praised by the manager for his attitude

    Serious
    Cause
    The discussion focused on his attitude.

  99. Personality clash with Enzo Fernández

    Minor
    Cause
    Their personalities have rubbed against each other for a while now. It played out behind the dressing-room door, away from the cameras.
    Outlook
    Repeated incidents may damage dressing-room status.

  100. To be loaned out

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board

  101. Loan withdrawn

    Decision
    Cause
    No club took him on loan before the window closed
    Who
    Board

  102. Being reassessed

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board

  103. Contract extension signed

    Decision
    Movement
    4y · $298.0K/y

  104. Contract renewal offered

    Decision
    Movement
    4y · $298.0K/y

  105. To be loaned out

    Decision
    Movement
    Development pathway updated
    Who
    Board